Theory: In the Clemens Point camp, there are people who come extremely close to the camp with their canoes, and Jack really likes to go near the water. What if Braithwaites secretly kidnapped Jack at night? That can explain how exactly the Braithwaites got so close to camp and took Jack.5yr ⋅ rockstar_fan ⋅ r/reddeadmysteries
Yesterday, a man came up to me and asked me to save his wife, so I did it, and I saved the location of that house which is the closest one to the Shady Belle, and when I came back after a day or two, I found this man, dead on the ground. Any ideas?5yr ⋅ rockstar_fan ⋅ r/reddeadmysteries
Abigail is the 2nd rat. She wanted to protect Jack so her and Micah destroyed the gang. She sent Jack and Arthur fishing and then Milton and Ross found them. And she got angry at Sadie and John when Sadie was finding leads on Micah. And this is an actual screenshot from the game, epilogue 2.5yr ⋅ rockstar_fan ⋅ r/reddeadmysteries
Bessy that the Valentine Saloon stranger mentions might be the same as Hoseas girlfriend Bessie. What do you think?4yr ⋅ rockstar_fan ⋅ r/reddeadmysteries
