In case I'm not the only listener who knows nothing about guns.1wk ⋅ SoggyDistribution182 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
If she’d been wearing those, we wouldn’t be here right now.4mo ⋅ not-a-regular-mom ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
James is giving people the business on Twitter for their stupid complaints about the show.3yr ⋅ hgerena ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
When it’s almost dinner time and Nonna says “Jimmy go pick the lawn.”2yr ⋅ mike95242 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
I sent in an episode recommendation two years ago, and it is now an episode! (Terra Linda, CA)9mo ⋅ mike95242 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Episode 393 Ark. City, KS: For anyone else who was wondering what Justin Thurber looks like.11mo ⋅ bfloblizzard ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
After this weeks Patreon episode here is a review of my small town that I thought deserved sharing1yr ⋅ xallymc ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
I wanted to share this from Facebook 😂 there’s a lot of other good ones too6mo ⋅ squid1980 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
I love me some James and his Italian jokes, but this is funny!4mo ⋅ Impressive_Yoghurt ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Just wanted to share from my hometown - Rhubarb Festival 2023 is coming! (Ep. 374: The Man in the Box - Kankakee, IL)1yr ⋅ drakethecat25 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
If you are listening on Spotify you can now give the podcast the five stars it deserves2yr ⋅ Tomtebobarnet ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
This is the panhandliest sleigh I've ever seen. It belongs here2yr ⋅ fuhnetically ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
“Because Baptists are the Catholics of the South.” Big ole Baptist Church in Cumberland, Maryland. Photo by me.1yr ⋅ beththebookgirl ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Opened an early Christmas present from the husband. Super excited!2yr ⋅ Creative_Donut1122 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
If you ever wanted to proof of how right james and jimmy are right about catholics, baptists, and LDS....11mo ⋅ th3t10m4n ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Not the best photo, but the show last night was amazing. Shout out to the murderers out there for making it happen.2yr ⋅ kramer69420 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Reasons for admission to Women’s Insane Asylum (1864-1889). Cheer up bitch!!3yr ⋅ mike95242 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
I'm so glad James and Jimmy don't have to rely on stand up gigs anymore.3yr ⋅ Penetratorofflanks ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
saw this on a tree in WA. Panhandle behavior at it's finest.2yr ⋅ Infamous_Ad8717 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
James joke about the Colby Cheese Murders made it onto the official Wikipedia page on the town!3yr ⋅ mike95242 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
In case anyone else didn’t know what they looked like. No one told me that they were actually attractive?? I’m shook.2yr ⋅ _Jelly_King_ ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Hiding bodies - found this in my local bookstore. (Chamblins, Jacksonville FL)3yr ⋅ jennjammin7 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
In 1995, 13 yo Thad Philips was kidnapped from his home by Joe Clark, aka the bone breaker killer. Held captive for almost 2 days, both his legs were broken and ankles were twisted until they snapped. He managed to escape and eventually walk again.2yr ⋅ hair_in_a_biscuit ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
You’ve heard of Pocket Robin, now get ready for Shit Hawk.11mo ⋅ Intelligent_Food4446 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Clown Motel. There has got to be some murder case related to this place ...2yr ⋅ saislo ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Taylor Swift announced a new album and one of the songs is No Body, No Crime. Wonder if she got the idea from James and Jimmie lol3yr ⋅ cmcnutty98 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
The Judgment Porch: You can sit out there and hate your neighbors!4yr ⋅ OnMatchPoint ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Visited Santa Claus, Georgia from episode 29 tonight with my girlfriend.4yr ⋅ ed40hands ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
i was looking to see if there was any updates on Michael Turney and seen this.1yr ⋅ allykay219 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
#140 - I haven’t hurt for a person more than I did this episode.4yr ⋅ Cobalt_Rave0087 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
I need James and Jimmy to find and talk about a murder that happened in Intercourse, Pennsylvania.2yr ⋅ mike95242 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Wonder if the guys would be interested in buying a small town?1yr ⋅ First_name_Lastname5 ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
Is Gormania the best name from the series? Gormania III inside the cage this Saturday night on PPV.1yr ⋅ aTrumpsterfire ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
I made a panhandle map. Note that “pan” areas may still exhibit pan handle behavior.5yr ⋅ Pretty_Pretty_Pizza ⋅ r/smalltownmurder
