Should I bring up my top pitching prospect for a September cup of coffee? He's 40 overall in ratings relative to MLB; 50 overall in RR to AAA. AAA season is over, would some MLB experience help him or is he not developed enough where it could hurt him? If I promote him, start or pitch him in relief?

2wk ⋅ ⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

Playoffs are underway for the first season of my Dog themed league

3yr ⋅

⋅

This prospect is almost 8 feet tall

2yr ⋅

⋅

snip snap snip snap snip snap

2yr ⋅

⋅

Julio's OSA Batting Ratings are Very Satisfying

1yr ⋅

⋅

Wish I had this guy playing for my cubs but holy shit he's insane

3yr ⋅

⋅

first libyan born player i've seen, and would also be the first in the mlb.

3yr ⋅

⋅

My first match ever ended in a walk-off grand slam!

2yr ⋅

⋅

New rookie ball manager

1yr ⋅

⋅

I present you the 2022 Dodgers

1yr ⋅

⋅

My reliever was awarded a save in a game I won 20-5

1yr ⋅

⋅

Best 3-year stretch by a reliever I've ever seen on this game.

1yr ⋅

⋅

This is my kind of SS

2yr ⋅

⋅

This guy just dropped a crazy -7.7 WAR in my fictional league. What's the lowest you guys have seen?

1yr ⋅

⋅

Is it worth re-signing Acuna at this stage? He wants $145m over 5 years.

1yr ⋅

⋅

I heard you guys like pure contact hitters (From an online league)

2yr ⋅

⋅

Made a huge trade for Juan Soto and signed him to a big extension...not exactly living up to it

2yr ⋅

⋅

On the same day Bryce Harper breaks the all-time Home Run record, Mike Trout retires after two failed seasons in the Minors, attempting to make it back to the Bigs to chase the record...

3yr ⋅

⋅

National Baseball League (NHL)

5yr ⋅

⋅

I think I'm in love

11mo ⋅

⋅

tough look at the futures game

3yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

One of the best rookie seasons I’ve ever had. Shame it was wasted a dud of a season

2yr ⋅

⋅

How do you pass on this speedster and allow him to fall to 13th overall?

1yr ⋅

⋅

Got a new owner and this might be the best thing that's happened to me in a long time in OOTP

5yr ⋅

⋅

Time to turn on draft pick trading

9mo ⋅

⋅

80 grade name

4yr ⋅

⋅

Welcome to OOTP 21

4yr ⋅

⋅

First game doing PbP, it's great fun. 162 games is going to take awhile though...

1yr ⋅

⋅

Found this ready made ace in the draft. Never seen anything like this before.

2yr ⋅

⋅

Growing up poor huh?

4yr ⋅

⋅

Prospect gave up more home runs than earned runs

2yr ⋅

⋅

What do you think of this guy? Still can't believe that I got him for just $1.8m from NC Dinos.

1yr ⋅

⋅

ACE OF SPADES

2yr ⋅

⋅

Ridiculous WS game 7

3yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

Baseball's Tom Brady

2mo ⋅

⋅

this guy is going to be terrorizing me for quite some time it seems.

3yr ⋅

⋅

Did the death penalty challenge for the Astros and won the WS by 2023. Details in comments.

4yr ⋅

⋅

I think I found my closer

4mo ⋅

⋅

Jeez no wonder this guy got drafted 1st overall

1yr ⋅

⋅

Played a lot of this game, never seen a pitcher add a new pitch. Anyone seen this before?

1yr ⋅

⋅

My created player threw a perfect game

6mo ⋅

⋅

The worst performance by a team I have witnessed (the Lions)

3yr ⋅

⋅

Just signed him as an international free agent. Where would you play him? Both 1B and a corner outfield spot are definitely fillable.

1yr ⋅

⋅

Doug Faulk, knuckleballer and all-time K king. First time I've had a player even come close to Nolan Ryan's record.

2yr ⋅

⋅

This might be the most well-developed rule 5 pick I've gotten. Seems like quite the oversight tbh. Also quite an interesting ratings profile.

3yr ⋅

⋅

I simmed until 2113, This pitcher has the record for k/9, h/9 and Opp Avg. What a wild career

1yr ⋅

⋅

We Retired His Number Today

3yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

What are the consequences of being overbudget ?

6mo ⋅

⋅

A story straight out of OOTP

5yr ⋅

⋅

Why is this pitchers WAR so high?

1yr ⋅

⋅

Can you imagine firing this Manager? The AI Cardinals fired their Manager who won 11 pennants in as many seasons and never won fewer then 98 games, because he couldn't win them their 6th consecutive World Series...

1yr ⋅

⋅

In 2021, the Dodgers break the win record leaving the Padres as a 101 win Wild Card team. Meanwhile, the Brewers win the NL Central at 80-82

3yr ⋅

⋅

Never seen anything like this in 20 years of playing OOTP

2yr ⋅

⋅

My Rookie that got his call up at the beginning of this season

2yr ⋅

⋅

Sometimes I sign future HOFs and give them a few games in their final year to try to help them win a World Series ring for the first time. It doesn't always work but it did for Yordan; he saw limited action for me in September after playing in AAA all year. He retired right after the season

4yr ⋅

⋅

Four two run homers in Game One of the World Series. By one dude

1yr ⋅

⋅

Started a new fictional league and found the best pitcher of all time

1yr ⋅

⋅

Vietnamese player with the nickname... Filipino?

3yr ⋅

⋅

Hall of Fame or no?

1yr ⋅

⋅

I'm typically one to shy away from paying relievers, but most definitely earned the high price tag this season. 41 SV; 0.78 ERA; .271 BABIP; 4.9 WAR - worth $13 mill

2yr ⋅

⋅

Was simming thru the playoffs of my first challenge mode Orioles Rebuild when this cursed image appeared in my inbox...

4yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

You've outdone yourself this time, OOTP Name Generator

5yr ⋅

⋅

Baseball Gods have forsaken us

8mo ⋅

⋅

Looks Like OOTP is Branching out to Corporate Sponsorship

2yr ⋅

⋅

Praying for a cure 🙏

2yr ⋅

⋅

My offense is, uh, good I guess

4yr ⋅

⋅

His bat will likely never come around but I had to draft this SUPER utility player

1yr ⋅

⋅

What winning the world series in 7 out of the last 10 seasons, and the last 4 years straight does for the market size in Milwaukee. Yet my owner won't let me have a team salary expense of over $170 MM without requesting a cut, so I Scrooge McDuck in my excess budget every season.

4yr ⋅

⋅

Just Your Casual 206.23 War Career For Gary Sheffield

1yr ⋅

⋅

Just saw my first 7 footer, what's your tallest?

3yr ⋅

⋅

Never seen a pitcher add a secondary pitch in 13 OOTPs. Is this new?

2yr ⋅

⋅

My SS has put up some of the best offensive and worst defensive numbers in my (1871 fictional) league. What should I do with him?

1yr ⋅

⋅

Rate this prospect cuz it might be my best ever

2yr ⋅

⋅

Update: The best hitting prospect I've ever seen had his first otherworldly season. Just barely missed a .500 OBP.

3yr ⋅

⋅

I think my bench coach is an idiot

3yr ⋅

⋅

On pace for about 120 HR’s, through 25 games....

3yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m very upset, please tell me this storyline has a happy ending 😭

2yr ⋅

⋅

Owen does WHAT!?

4yr ⋅

⋅

Why are all the bench coaches belgian?? (From a live start save made today)

1yr ⋅

⋅

The ole 100 WAR in 10 seasons special

1yr ⋅

⋅

I've been taking any job offered during a full historical re-sim. Fun stuff. Fired twice.

2yr ⋅

⋅

Player goes independent - insanity ensues

1yr ⋅

⋅

Despite accumulating only 4.6 WAR since the start of 2028, this guy I traded for has won 3 rings in 3 years with 3 different teams.

1yr ⋅

⋅

PINCH HIT WALK OFF GRAND SLAM IN GAME 7 OF THE WORLD SERIES I LOVE THIS GAME!!!!!!!!!

2yr ⋅

⋅

The next Ricky Henderson? Fast, bats right, throws left, plus eye, plus contact, plus outfield and he is a prankster with nickname abnormal

4yr ⋅

⋅

This doesn’t seem like a healthy metagame

2yr ⋅

⋅

Can I play him at second base?

8mo ⋅

⋅

And I thought my team was having a good year

4yr ⋅

⋅

Through his first 69 AB's of 22', Franco's maintaining a .420 AVG :)

3yr ⋅

⋅

Best season I’ve ever seen from a reliever

2yr ⋅

⋅

Wanted to see what would happen in a fictional league if you made a pitcher with nothing special other than control and some stamina. Behold, the Trashmaster.

2mo ⋅

⋅

Rough Start for the Mets

4yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

Just a couple weeks into this save and my scout drops this guy in my lap

2yr ⋅

⋅

654 ERA+. 0.72 ERA for the year. 0 runs allowed in all of August or September. 0.58 WHIP and 19.6 K/9. The most dominant season for a closer I've ever seen

2yr ⋅

⋅

Having the worst offseason I've had since I've been playing OOTP. Fan interest down 30 points, next year's projected budget has dropped by $15 million already

2yr ⋅

⋅

What exactly is their process to come up with these nicknames?

2yr ⋅

⋅

Oh No... Not The Guru... Anybody But The Guru.

8mo ⋅

⋅

You never know where your next superstar is going to come from. My 21st round pick from 2021 just exploded in the past year.

2yr ⋅

⋅

Royals had turned into the Fischer Cats. And now, they've moved into the (Swamp)Dog house?!

4mo ⋅

⋅

In 2028, Amed Rosario, age 32, falls 8 games short of Joe DiMaggio's hitting streak from 1941, taking the second-place spot with a 48-game hitting streak.

3yr ⋅

⋅

Set up a fictional league and simmed through until 2050. While checking back through the league's history, I found hands down the greatest pitcher I have ever seen. 9 Triple crowns, 11 10+ war seasons, and 5000+ career strikeouts. The GOAT

6mo ⋅

⋅

The year is 2087. The San Antonio Saints are World Series champs for the second time in their history, ending the Angels streak at 3. The AL and NL were scrapped in the late 70’s for an East/West Conference structure. The highest paid player makes $144 Million per year.

2yr ⋅

⋅

18 BF limit on all my starters = 20 win long reliever

1yr ⋅

⋅

Very proud of this season 116 wins and won it all!

4mo ⋅

⋅

Shohei Ohtani- after looking like he was going to be just average- put together the greatest season I've ever seen.

2yr ⋅

⋅

OOTP Dev confirms draft development is bugged at the moment, will be fixed for the next patch

2yr ⋅

⋅

Do I promote this international signing to Florida Rookie yet?

1yr ⋅

⋅

This is what a Meddling owner will do to you. He likes Extreme Winning so I won 119 games for him. (and of course lost in the ALDS) Made him $42m. So he cuts the draft budget from $8m to $1.5m. Guess our top 3 picks this year are gone. Challenge mode, so no commissioner mode.

3yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

Most absurd player development I've seen

7mo ⋅

⋅

The most developed draft prospect I have ever laid my eyes upon

2yr ⋅

⋅

I've had some crazy names before but now I think the game's just trolling me.

4yr ⋅

⋅

Noticed this guy in toiling away my in minor league system and he's not happy, should I be worried?

1yr ⋅

⋅

An absolute OOTP Legend. Broke the all-time hits record in a 20-year career, never played a day in his 40s, a Gold Glove, 11 All-Star Teams, 10 Silver Sluggers, 6 Rings, a career .336 average, and a positive pitching WAR. His last game was a World Series win.

3yr ⋅

⋅

I'm sorry, off what now?

3yr ⋅

⋅

Something seems wrong here. He was 6'2 (188cm) in real life.

3yr ⋅

⋅

Started a historical league in the 80s and Ellis Burks’ 2000 season is the worst I’ve ever seen

8mo ⋅

⋅

I created a bird themed OOTP league. Wanted to share my logos with this sub!

5yr ⋅

⋅

Worst season I've ever seen

1yr ⋅

⋅

Today in statistical performances I've never seen before: 20+ saves and 20+ losses.

1yr ⋅

⋅

Always frontload your contracts

4yr ⋅

⋅

the craziest cy voting I've ever seen

2yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

Why are my pitching prospects always Very Unhappy with their Role on Team?

1yr ⋅

⋅

Doctor walks in. Yep, you've been kicked by a horse.

6yr ⋅

⋅

If I ever need a pitcher to go 7-9 I've got my guy

4yr ⋅

⋅

What Should I Do With Him?

2yr ⋅

⋅

when your 26 year old AAAA rookie PM's you demanding a trade to a winning franchise because your team is 5 games under .500

1yr ⋅

⋅

Still on OOTP 19, made some force trades to accelerate a rebuild. Should I got ahead and lock these in to 10 year deals without playing in the majors?

1yr ⋅

⋅

Down 9-1, my team refuses to give up and ends up winning 37-17

1yr ⋅

⋅

The weirdest relief prospect I've seen, how does this add up to 80/80 potential?

2yr ⋅

⋅

The Ballad of Trevor Brock and the Saddest Month in Human History

1yr ⋅

⋅

2022 Tatis puts up an insane 11.3 WAR, most since Bonds in '02 iirc

2yr ⋅

⋅

I don't think I've ever wanted a prospect to pan out more

1yr ⋅

⋅

The 2040's Yankees will forever haunt my dreams

1yr ⋅

⋅

Starter, Reliever or Trade Bait?

1yr ⋅

⋅

ADVERTISEMENT

Just swept the Yomiuri Giants in 3 games with my Carp. Considering they're the best team in NPB and I'm a bit struggling, made my day.

3yr ⋅

⋅

1st Sim of season for Peeradat Trongcharoenchai in AAA ball.

10mo ⋅

⋅

10 straight Cy Young's, and counting

4yr ⋅

⋅

What is your strategy with under-performer like this?

6mo ⋅

⋅

Had this occur in one of my games, I managed to score a grand slam off an inside the park homer

3yr ⋅

⋅

Your move, OOTP name generator

3yr ⋅

⋅

Sharing the player the game thinks I'd get from the Mock Draft pages. I can kinda see the approach but I'm not sure if this will be the guy when I actually draft.

1yr ⋅

⋅

40 year old starter wins his 3rd cy young, 12 years after his first

2yr ⋅

⋅

Three time MVP just posted a season with 51 homers and 7 doubles. What a bizarre profile.

1yr ⋅

⋅

Kills me when my franchise players, in this case, the greatest position player to ever wear a Brewers uniform refuses to retire despite no longer having it. I feel I owe them the right to play and go out on their own terms, but hard to do so when it's a detriment to team success.

4yr ⋅

⋅

Fan Favorite Rodriguez smh

4yr ⋅

⋅

What the AI has put together for the Yankees 2036 roster - Wander, Julio, Torkelson and Mayer

1yr ⋅

⋅

Let me play him a song on the world's smallest violin

4yr ⋅

⋅